logoalt Hacker News

alhazrodtoday at 12:47 AM16 repliesview on HN

I remember before Little Snitch there was ZoneAlarm for Windows[0] (here is a good screenshot[1]). No clue if the current version of ZoneAlarm does anything like that (have not used it in 2 decades). I always found it weird that Linux never really had anything like it.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZoneAlarm

[1]: https://d2nwkt1g6n1fev.cloudfront.net/helpmax/wp-content/upl...


Replies

JetSetIllytoday at 5:36 AM

I wrote a program similar to this for AmigaOS many, many years ago. I would have been inspired by ZoneAlarm or a program like it.

I've just found it and uploaded it to github. Looking at the code, I can see my horrible C style of the time. There's probably bugs galore.

https://github.com/JetSetIlly/Direwall

If I remember correctly, it runs as a commodity and patches the socket library. Interestingly, the socket library was not re-entrant (unusual for Amiga libraries) so I had to patch the Exec OpenLibrary() function to monitor the loading of new copies of the socket library. But it's been a long time so memories are hazy.

It'll be interesting to see if it is still compiles and runs for modern AmigaOS, if any active Amiga programmers are around to see.

philipstorrytoday at 11:53 AM

What I really liked about ZoneAlarm wasn't just that it was a very nice technology - and it was; but also that it got the user expectations and training right from a very early stage.

It was quite insistent on the fact that it would be "noisy" at first as it queried all the programs you ran, but would then quieten down once it had been "trained". It got that across in clear, simple language.

I think it was so successful because it got the soft side of its security job right as well as the hard part. It's certainly why I recommended it to anyone at the time...

orangesilktoday at 6:35 AM

> [ZoneAlarm] I always found it weird that Linux never really had anything like it.

There was simply no need for it. GNU provided most of the software, spyware was unknown.

Only since comercial vendors package for linux and bring their spyware along, the desire to inspect network rose.

show 1 reply
brandon272today at 1:33 AM

Completely forgot about ZoneAlarm. I remember using it in the early 2000s!

show 5 replies
alex0comtoday at 1:50 AM

This reminded me of running Kerio Personal Firewall. When Kerio ended I switched to either ZA or Comodo firewall, one of them introduced a neat feature of running executables in containers. Made clicking random things so much easier. But the best part with all of these was restricting windows to where it could barely do anything. "RandomXYZ.DLL wants to execute random what and connect to random where? I dont think so MS." lol

Scroungertoday at 4:20 AM

Who remembers BlackICE Defender tho?

https://archive.org/details/BlackICE_Defender

show 1 reply
VerTiGo_Etrextoday at 3:43 AM

Wow. Insane throwback. I think I first learned about ZoneAlarm from some PC magazine my parents bought for me. Completely forgot about this great piece of freemium!

show 2 replies
tostitoday at 10:40 AM

I ran ntop on a router in 2001. It had a highly insightful overview of traffic with nice looking diagrams and everything. There hasn't been anything like that since as far as I'm aware.

ZoneAlarm otoh, was snakeoil. Programs that ran at the same privilege level (typically everything) could bypass it in various ways.

avazhitoday at 5:16 AM

Back in the Halo 2 days ZoneAlarm and Cain and Abel were the go-to host bridging and bluescreen programs.

A simpler time lol.

Used to use Outpost Firewall Pro, too.

show 1 reply
jerukmanggatoday at 1:43 AM

It's interesting hw lng it took for linux to get a user friendly application firewall like OpenSnitch

show 1 reply
kaspersettoday at 3:23 AM

There was also Tiny Firewall which got bought by Computer Associates around 2005. Probably the most complicated or fine grain control for me at that time in Windows XP.

show 1 reply
DerSaidintoday at 5:59 AM

For me it was Sygate personal firewall back on windows xp

pachouli-pleasetoday at 3:37 AM

i loved zonealarm! and also pained myself with all the little rules and upkeep lol

latentpottoday at 7:10 AM

It was problematic, so we moved to blackice defender iirc

laweijfmvotoday at 1:23 AM

isn’t this essentially built into Windows these days? although it seems to come with a lot of programs pre-approved.

show 3 replies
poglettoday at 12:56 AM

[flagged]

show 1 reply