logoalt Hacker News

mint5today at 5:38 AM1 replyview on HN

How does making a wager cause insider info to be public? All it means is an anonymous account placed money on the outcome, how does it make public anything that an insider knows? It doesn’t.

It incentives them to keep the info secret in order to profit or a wager on a related outcome. The insider info remains secret, all people know is some bloke stood up a new account and placed a big bet.

And for these short timespan bets, it seems utterly useless. If the wagers were only allowed on things two weeks out, and not allow bets on short term events then maybe it could show more info.


Replies

nltoday at 6:18 AM

The price movement is the indicator that there is insider information.

Of course there are lots of problems with this theory - in large markets a single trader has to make large bets to move the market, and with the current leadership the price moves large amounts unpredictably as well based on the latest statements.

But the mechanism itself makes sense.

It's unclear if that's a good thing. Of course some people know secret information before hand. Is disclosing that always good?

show 2 replies