logoalt Hacker News

zarzavattoday at 8:19 AM1 replyview on HN

If Mr Carreyrou is such a good writer then he should be embarrassed to publish trash:

> In keeping with this belief, Mr. Back made his Hashcash spam-throttling software open source.

> Satoshi did a similar thing. He released the Bitcoin software under M.I.T.’s open-source license, which allowed anyone to use, modify and distribute it without restrictions.

The numerous observations such as this only seem impressive to people who don't know anything at all about the subject. Occam's Razor suggests that the reason that such irrelevant observations were included is because Carreyrou doesn't know anything at all about the subject.

> When we compared those errors with the writings of our hundreds of suspects, Mr. Back was a clear outlier. He shared 67 of Satoshi’s exact hyphenation errors. The person with the second-most matches had 38.

The article does not improve.


Replies

storystraighttoday at 12:35 PM

You’re talking about “Occam’s razor” while noticing things in an article that may not be relevant while informing huge swathes of the article.

Occam’s razor suggests you’re doing this because you want the article to be wrong and want to pretend to be a genius, not because you actually think it is