logoalt Hacker News

CGMthrowawayyesterday at 5:07 PM6 repliesview on HN

There's way too much misdirected emphasis on the pope and ecclesiastical hierarchy imo. I wouldn't think too hard about it. You can be catholic and not like the pope just the same as you can be french and not like the king. Or american and not like the president. There is only one divinity on earth today and that's the holy spirit (consubstantial with the father and son), indwelling and guiding humanity on many levels


Replies

Galanweyesterday at 6:44 PM

> You can be catholic and not like the pope

You can be christian and not like the pope.

But to catholics, the pope is the terrestrial embodiment of the holy spirit, and as such considered infaillible. Not recognizing the pope as such is incompatible with catholicism.

Papacy is a core part of catholicism, it's not a "pick and choose buffet".

show 1 reply
Arodexyesterday at 8:59 PM

>You can be catholic and not like the pope

Quick, read the Nicene creed aloud right now...

sqirclesyesterday at 5:22 PM

I appreciate your comment and I understand. My struggles are not about whether or not I like the man who is in the seat.

show 1 reply
fhdkweigyesterday at 6:06 PM

> You can be catholic and not like the pope

I come from a Protestant background, so I view Catholicism as just Protestants with a pope. What does it mean to be catholic but without a pope?

show 2 replies
habineroyesterday at 5:19 PM

> you can be french and not like the king

Famously the French got rid of theirs, several times. Maybe not the best example.

show 1 reply
lostloginyesterday at 6:18 PM

> can be french and not like the king.

I don’t think you can? You know how that worked out? It’s the OG ‘No Kings’.