logoalt Hacker News

trashfaceyesterday at 5:33 PM6 repliesview on HN

I'm ex-catholic but not quite sure the "we want to be free to oppress catholics" narrative quite holds up in the case of the trump admin.

The current supreme court has 6 catholic justices, with 2 appointed by trump. 2 of them rubber stamp everything trump does (alito and thomas), and most of the others support him more often than not (rogers, coney-barrett, kavanaugh). Only sotomayor opposes him frequently.

If you covertly (or not) want to oppress a religion why stack the highest court in the country with people from said religion?


Replies

epistasisyesterday at 5:35 PM

I think the point is that it's a (temporary) coalition of the factions that joined together in order to get a leader elected, a leader which is in fact not religious at all and can not be considered to be a member of any of the factions. That temporary coalition will fall apart once faction members are given power in various domains, and then can enact their own faction's preferences, which involve harming other factions.

Arodexyesterday at 5:48 PM

I know the "flooding the zone with shit" strategy of MAGA/GOP strategists works somewhat at burying relevant information, but improve your searching skills a bit and this is just one example of what you'll find:

Pentagon To Host Good Friday Service Just For Protestants, Not Catholics

https://www.huffpost.com/entry/news-live-updates_n_69ca6616e...

mullingitoveryesterday at 5:37 PM

That's easy, the circular firing squad points outward until you've shot everyone else.

lostloginyesterday at 6:34 PM

I think that assuming religion is relevant is wrong. Their moral bankruptcy was what got them their jobs, their religion is secondary and irrelevant.

dhosekyesterday at 5:41 PM

Because they figure those two will flip to their side if forced to make a choice. Note for example that Pete Hegseth made an explicit choice to exclude Catholic worship from the Pentagon chapel this past Good Friday.

ImJamalyesterday at 8:05 PM

Trump doesn't care if somebody is a Catholic. Many of the people around Trump do.