logoalt Hacker News

satvikpendemtoday at 7:18 AM2 repliesview on HN

Just use the Ask button on YouTube videos to summarize, that's what it's for.


Replies

jasodetoday at 10:19 AM

>Just use the Ask button on YouTube videos to summarize,

For anyone confused because they don't see the "Ask" button between the Share and Bookmark buttons...

It looks like you have to be signed-in to Youtube to see it. I always browse Youtube in incognito mode so I never saw the Ask button.

Another source of confusion is that some channels may not have it or some other unexplained reason: https://old.reddit.com/r/youtube/comments/1qaudqd/youtube_as...

dspilletttoday at 9:49 AM

Not complaining about the particular presenter here, this is an interesting video with some decent content, I don't find the presentation style overly irritating, and it is documenting a lot of work that has obviously been done experimenting in order to get the end result (rather than just summarising someone else's work). Such a goofy elongated style, that is infuriating if you are looking for quick hard information, is practically required in order to drive wider interest in the channel.

But the “ask the LLM” thing is a sign of how off kilter information passing has become in the current world. A lot of stuff is packaged deliberately inefficiently because that is the way to monetise it, or sometimes just to game the searching & recommendation systems so it gets out to potentially interested people at all, then we are encouraged to use a computationally expensive process to summarise that to distil the information back out.

MS's documentation the large chunks of Azure is that way, but with even less excuse (they aren't a content creator needing to drive interest by being a quirky presenter as well as a potential information source). Instead of telling me to ask copilot to guess what I need to know, why not write some good documentation that you can reference directly (or that I can search through)? Heck, use copilot to draft that documentation if you want to (but please have humans review the result for hallucinations, missed parts, and other inaccuracies, before publishing).

show 1 reply