logoalt Hacker News

Peritracttoday at 1:52 PM1 replyview on HN

If I tell someone to kill someone else and they do, then I should be held responsible.

If I write instructions in a book that I give to someone telling them to kill someone else and they do, then I should be held responsible.

If I give someone a tool I made that I bill as more-than-PhD-level intelligence and it tells someone to kill someone else and they do, then I should be held responsible.

All of the above situations seem equivalent to me; I'm not the only person responsible in each case, but I gave them instructions and they followed them.


Replies

jstummbilligtoday at 2:35 PM

Man, this debate is both very interesting and highly confusing with different people oscillating between "It's just a tool" and "It's a human being+"

show 1 reply