logoalt Hacker News

pixel_poppingyesterday at 7:23 PM6 repliesview on HN

I agree it is scary, but why would a robot take healthcare away? Wouldn't that be the contrary?


Replies

WBrentWilliamsyesterday at 7:39 PM

The quickest way to rile up an existing mob is to make them fear their livelihood is being reduced or removed. The _robot_ is not taking away healthcare, but the effect of the robot existing hit directly at the livelihood of the masses.

In the US, health insurance is largely tied to employment. Health insurance, in a personal economic sense, reduces to being able to pay for healthcare. This policy is largely a left-over of World War II era employment policies. No one is taking healthcare _away_ from anyone (strictly speaking), but the ability to be able to _pay_ for healthcare is reduced to zero when employment ceases. Accessing the safety net is a separate skillset. This skill set becomes more difficult to achieve because the political class does not want to provide healthcare for everyone, only the worthy (their loyal voters).

I grew up in and am still a member of the precariat. I am educated and doing well, but I wear a well-polished pair of golden handcuffs due to how my ability to afford healthcare for myself, and my family, is tied to employment. Politically, I _do not_ like being tied to my employer by such a chain, but my arguments to change the system have been met with quite firm push-back.

show 1 reply
ironman1478yesterday at 7:26 PM

There are stories about insurance companies using AI when determining if a claim should be let through or denied.

https://www.palmbeachpost.com/story/news/healthcare/2026/03/...

show 1 reply
whimblepopyesterday at 7:25 PM

Because healthcare in the US is tied to employment. For most people here, losing a job means losing access to healthcare (partially or totally).

cryptonymyesterday at 7:28 PM

Because the robot would take their job and having a job is a precondition to healthcare (may vary by country)?

show 1 reply
sophaclesyesterday at 7:35 PM

Well in the US you get healthcare from a job (either directly in the form of insurance or indirectly in the form the money to pay for healthcare). If the robot takes your job, it takes your healthcare too.

You know this, stop pretending otherwise.

therobots927yesterday at 7:25 PM

1. Americans need a job to get healthcare

2. Robots take away jobs from Americans and the proceeds to go the owner (investor) class

3. Americans no longer have healthcare

Understand?

show 1 reply