logoalt Hacker News

mkprcyesterday at 9:29 PM4 repliesview on HN

Sniff test: a paper with a single author and 53 revisions, listing a gmail address as contact information despite the author, after a brief internet search, appearing to have affiliations with CSU Global, (maybe) the University of Central Florida, and the San Jose State University Department of Aerospace.


Replies

iliatoliyesterday at 9:33 PM

Author here. Three PhDs (Mathematics, Pisa; Quantum Chemistry, UCF; Materials Science, UTD — in progress), plus MS degrees from SJSU and CSU. The gmail is because this is independent work, not affiliated with any institution. v53 reflects thirteen years of development since the original 2013 publication (Graphene 1, 107–109). The barrier is verified at two independent levels of theory with a confirmed transition state. Happy to discuss the physics.

show 6 replies
ilakshyesterday at 9:53 PM

Sniff test as in you turned your nose up without even looking at it on a purely surface level based on affiliation.

Smells like laziness to me.

show 1 reply
doctorpanglossyesterday at 10:02 PM

I suppose anyone can run the same computer simulations.

show 1 reply