logoalt Hacker News

teaearlgraycold • today at 8:37 AM • 2 replies • view on HN

The main problem with TypeScript is the default compiler flags are not safe. I understand having things weak when you’re getting the ecosystem up and running, before you have wide adoption. You don’t want to throw too many red squigglies at early adopters and cause them to give up. But these days the default should not allow any. No implicit any. No explicit any. The stdlib should not use it. JSON.parse() should return either unknown or a recursive union that defines all valid JSON structures.

I believe it’s largely because of these defaults that the idea that TypeScript isn’t really checking types persists. Without the any type, or loose undefined and null checks, your types are as validated as they can be. The only failure point is deserialization or an import which doesn’t type check. And deserialization has this problem in every language.

When you compile C to machine code the executed binary isn’t checking types. This is no different from Typescript that’s been compiled to JavaScript.

Replies

sargunv • today at 8:55 AM

Even with strict flags on, there are failures. A trivial example:

  function mutateArray(
    arr: (string | number)[]
  ) {
    arr.push(1);
  }
  const a: string[] = ["one", "two"];
  mutateArray(a);
a is now a string[] with a number inside
➕ show 4 replies
Tade0 • today at 10:58 AM

> You don’t want to throw too many red squigglies at early adopters and cause them to give up.

That's not the reason.

TypeScript's main design goal was to enable developers to gradually introduce types in codebases that spent years being written purely in JS.

There's still demand for this feature and those who start off with TypeScript set their own config anyway.

I've dealt with people using all kinds of escape hatches, but 2/3 of the time it's caused by lack of proficiency in the language.

The rest is either someone being in a hurry or just not serious about their job.