logoalt Hacker News

yukIttEfttoday at 9:55 AM5 repliesview on HN

I'm currently "working" on a toy 3d Vulkan Physx thingy. It has a simple raycast vehicle and I'm trying to replace it with the PhysX5 built in one (https://nvidia-omniverse.github.io/PhysX/physx/5.6.1/docs/Ve...)

I point it to example snippets and webdocumentation but the code it gens won't work at all, not even close

Opus4.6 is a tiny bit less wrong than Codex 5.4 xhigh, but still pretty useless.

So, after reading all the success stories here and everywhere, I'm wondering if I'm holding it wrong or if it just can't solve everything yet.


Replies

neomantratoday at 2:10 PM

While I’ve had tremendous success with Golang projects and Typescript Web Apps, when I tried to use Metal Mesh Shaders in January, both Codex and Claude both had issues getting it right.

That sort of GPU code has a lot of concepts and machinery, it’s not just a syntax to express, and everything has to be just right or you will get a blank screen. I also use them differently than most examples; I use it for data viz (turning data into meshes) and most samples are about level of detail. So a double whammy.

But once I pointed either LLM at my own previous work — the code from months of my prior personal exploration and battles for understanding, then they both worked much better. Not great, but we could make progress.

I also needed to make more mini-harnesses / scaffolds for it to work through; in other words isolating its focus, kind of like test-driven development.

layer8today at 1:29 PM

My impression is that it always comes down to how well what you’re trying to do pattern-matches the training set.

show 1 reply
lukantoday at 10:24 AM

" or if it just can't solve everything yet."

Obviously it cannot. But if you give the AI enough hints, clear spec, clear documentation and remove all distracting information, it can solve most problems.

seba_dos1today at 10:45 AM

It works somewhat well with trivial things. That's where most of these success stories are coming from.

wg0today at 12:41 PM

Most of the folks are building CRUD apps with AI and that works fine.

What you're doing is more specialized and these models are useless there. It's not intelligence.

Another NFT/Crypto era is upon us so no you're not holding it wrong.

show 1 reply