logoalt Hacker News

thunkytoday at 1:20 PM4 repliesview on HN

> AI is just a dumb parrot

You really need to look again. If you're still manually writing code you have your head in the sand.

AI can produce better code than most devs produce. This is true for easy stuff like crud apps and even more true for harder problems that require knowledge of external domains.


Replies

prmphtoday at 1:27 PM

Well "most" devs is doing a lot of work here.

I'm not sure about other devs, or even their number, but AI can most definitely NOT produce better code than I can.

I use it after I have done the hard architectural work: defining complex types and interfaces, figuring out code organization, solving thorny issues. When these are done, it's now time to hand over to the agent to apply stuff everywhere following my patterns. And even there SOTA model like Opus make silly mistakes, you need to watch them carefully. Sometimes it loses track of the big picture.

I also use them to check my code and to write bash scripts. They are useful for all these.

show 1 reply
SpicyLemonZesttoday at 2:50 PM

You’re equating two things that aren’t the same. I’m not still manually writing code, but it’s not at all because Claude can produce better code than me. It’s worse at CRUD apps and a lot worse at domain specific bits. But it’s more parallelizable, so if I drive it well I can focus my skill on the small subset of problems that actually require it and achieve increased throughput.

moi2388today at 1:22 PM

It can produce better code than most devs in the hands of a good dev. The bullshit code I see coming from juniors using AI..

show 1 reply
throwaway613746today at 1:35 PM

[dead]