logoalt Hacker News

lotsofpulpyesterday at 3:19 PM5 repliesview on HN

Good luck taking away the detached single family homes, pickup trucks, SUVs, commercial flights, out of season fruits/vegetables, and imported manufactured goods. The people that expect those things are the “ small number of people hoarding a majority of the wealth”, and there are quite a few of them (probably 1B+ worldwide).


Replies

elevatortrimyesterday at 6:16 PM

Is what you say really controversial?

Except for commercial flights (which I would easily give up for a hopeful society), I do not find anything on your list remotely relevant to my happiness or well-being.

Imported cheap goods are obviously something all of us consume a lot, but we only need them to feel good in comparison to our neighbours.

As long as we keep them for hospitals and medicine, the rest going away would be just fine. Children would play with whatever they can find instead of cheap plastic toys, we would have to learn to multi-purpose our tools instead of having a specific object for every minor purpose.

Loughlayesterday at 5:14 PM

There is a wild difference between asking people not to eat apples in December in the northern hemisphere and asking people not to move wealth around to avoid paying taxes when they have more resources available to them than multiple countries.

Comparing middle income 1st world citizens to dragons on their mountains of gold is disingenuous at best.

show 1 reply
underliptonyesterday at 7:11 PM

Most of the younger people don't care about most of those things. That preference just isn't reflected in markets because older generations control a disproportionate (unfair) portion of wealth.

UltraSaneyesterday at 4:03 PM

Comparing those people to the richest few thousand people in the US and Europe is very disingenuous.

show 2 replies
Liongayesterday at 4:06 PM

No, no, no you get that all wrong. MY lifestyle is just about fine and okay. but the ones above me should all pay more.