logoalt Hacker News

Let's Talk Space Toilets

91 pointsby zdwyesterday at 10:41 PM33 commentsview on HN

Comments

assimpleaspossitoday at 7:37 PM

I've always wondered about regular toilets and now this. Someone has to test it. I'm sure they have equivalent items to run through them but, eventually, you have to try the real thing so whose job is it to do that and how do they do that?

show 2 replies
detourdogtoday at 5:26 PM

I was surprised there were no pictures of the actual toilets. Would love more but found this.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_toilet

show 2 replies
gritspantstoday at 9:21 PM

I've often wondered - what is the exact amount of vacuum (pressure?) that you can get away with without disemboweling someone?

show 1 reply
ooternesstoday at 6:29 PM

Is it simpler to build a better space toilet, or to build a ship with centrifugal gravity and use a regular toilet?

show 7 replies
bdammtoday at 7:13 PM

The roasting process is both hypermodern and curiously antique. Burning dung is a tradition passed down across the millenia!

nozzlegeartoday at 5:28 PM

> One piece of feedback from Skylab was that the toilet needed stronger airflow. This meant the Shuttle toilet opening had to be narrow. To practice correctly positioning their body, astronauts on Earth sat on a special training mockup with a camera mounted in the center of the waste tube. A successful docking with the device meant precisely centering one’s nether eye in the crosshairs of a video screen while crewmates looked on and yelled their encouragement.

I knew part of the job for astronauts is being intimate with one's crewmates, but I didn't know it was that intimate.

show 2 replies
ambicaptertoday at 5:27 PM

Not a great lunch read.

the_aftoday at 5:07 PM

This story of space toilers clears out many questions I had about spaceflight and... uh, going number 2.

Namely: astronauts try NOT to as much as they can, and when they do go, it's a mess for both them and their crew mates. They suffer through it because being in space is a worthy achievement.

Apparently it's such a mess that NASA estimates this is why astronauts tend to undereat. Apparently Gemini 7's Frank Borman spent 9 days without going number 2 because of this, and planned to hold it in 2 full weeks (the article doesn't clarify whether he managed). Skylab seems to have done some progress, but we're still in the early eras of space toiletry!

show 1 reply
nQQKTz7dm27oZtoday at 5:01 PM

[dead]