logoalt Hacker News

Someonetoday at 5:28 AM2 repliesview on HN

> when we speak of bugs in a verified software system, I think it's fair to consider the entire binary a fair target.

I agree, but it’s not fair to imply that the verification was incorrect if the problem lies elsewhere.

This is a nice example of how careful you have to be to build a truly verified system.


Replies

amosstoday at 6:24 AM

But is fair to state that the verification was *incomplete*, which is what the article does.

lmmtoday at 5:51 AM

The problem was in Lean though, so it seems fair.