It's awesome that they're adding a UI for stacked branches¹! The UX of the CLI tool seems weird, though. Why do I need to explicitly create and add branches to the stack if all I really want is to open PRs from my commits? Here's the workflow that I built for myself instead:

∙ `git checkout -b feature-branch-xyz`

∙ make a few commits, perhaps some fixups, rebase, whatever

∙ start tig, look at the history, decide at which points I want to break the branch into stacked PRs, and mark those points using shift-s (which calls my own `git gh-stack branch create $commit` and creates a specially named branch there)

∙ `git gh-stack sync` — collects all the specially named branches, builds a graph of how they're stacked on one another, pushes them, opens stacked PRs

GitHub has had some "support" for stacked PRs for a while, so merging the first one to main will automatically change the target branch of the second to main.

If I need to change anything, I can just `git rebase --interactive --update-refs`, amend commits, split commits, rearrange commits, and then running `git gh-stack sync` will update the PRs for me. If I split a commit in the middle and shift-s to mark it, it will open an extra PR and restack everything to update the order.

Furthermore, the "PR stack" doesn't actually need to be a stack (linear chain), it can be a tree. If I know that some commits are independent of the rest, I don't need to create a separate stack, I just create another local branch, mark PR-ready commits with shift-s, and `git gh-stack sync` will do the right thing. If I need to rebase the whole tree on top of current main, then `git rebase -i --rebase-merges --update-refs` does the job.

I guess what I'm saying is that as someone who's been using git since its inception, it feels much more natural to just do everything in git, and then have a single command that pushes my work to GitHub. And I think this might work even better with jujutsu — just point `git gh-stack sync` at the branches jj makes and it'll make a stack/tree of PRs out of them. :-)

https://github.com/liskin/dotfiles/blob/home/bin/git-gh-stac... if anyone's curious. It's just a few hundred lines of code. Building the graph is done by `git log --simplify-by-decoration`. Opening PRs is shelled out to `gh pr create`.

¹) I mean, I'd much rather they added a UI for reviewing PRs commit-by-commit, with the option to approve/request-changes on each, and the possibility to merge the first few approved ones while continuing work on the rest… But in a world of almost every $dayjob insisting on squash-merging, a UI for stacked PRs is a total game changer, positively.