logoalt Hacker News

R00mitoday at 4:31 PM1 replyview on HN

MCP is the wire format between agent and tool, not the format the model itself uses to emit the call. That part (Harmony, JSON, XML-ish) is still model-specific. So the M×N the article describes is really two problems stacked — MCP only solves the lower half.

Also in practice Claude Code, Cursor and Codex handle the same MCP tool differently — required params, tool descriptions, response truncation. So MCP gives you the contract but the client UX still leaks.


Replies

hedgehogtoday at 4:42 PM

But, like pancakes, usually the stack is described as building bottom-up. Can you relate the individual components to ingredients in a diner-style pancake breakfast?

show 1 reply