logoalt Hacker News

binarymaxtoday at 2:24 PM4 repliesview on HN

Nonsense bills get introduced all the time. I’m not saying this shouldn’t be taken seriously, but this eventually getting codified is a long shot.

There are so many issues with how this can work in practice. Best case it just asks how old you are like a website that shows mature content, and the user lies. So from a liability perspective that shifts it to the user who gave false information. Beyond that there’s no practical way to actually verify someone’s age at the OS level.


Replies

WarmWashtoday at 3:25 PM

>Beyond that there’s no practical way to actually verify someone’s age at the OS level.

KYC for windows, MacOS, iOS, Android, and internet players like Google and Cloudflare being forced to block unverified devices.

There probably would still be a way around it, but it would be a headache for most people.

forshapertoday at 3:04 PM

Age verification in general rolled out so fast, I'm more inclined to think that nonsense gets passed more easily if it enables going after drastically more control.

bovermyertoday at 2:26 PM

You're assuming that politicians are competent, thorough, and consider all the implications before writing a bill or voting on a bill.

That is a _very_ dangerous assumption.

cucumber3732842today at 2:36 PM

The government doesn't care if it's nonsensical and contradictory and enforcement would be a dumpster fire because all that essentially grants their buddies (if not now then in the future) in the executive more power.