logoalt Hacker News

pelasacotoday at 10:57 AM6 repliesview on HN

What’s the point? People will just fork it and improve it with AI anyway. In another hand, it would be an interesting experiment to watch how the original and the fork diverge over time. Especially in terms of security discoveries and feature development.


Replies

sphtoday at 11:07 AM

Go ahead, we're all still waiting for these "AI-improved" projects to appear.

Meanwhile I'll keep using SDL from the official maintainers which have been working on it for decades.

show 1 reply
raincoletoday at 12:02 PM

I'm pretty pro-AI, but I find it very amusing that every single time an open source project enacts no-AI policy, someone will chime in and explain how it will be outcompeted by the yes-AI version, while in reality it never happens.

show 1 reply
arnvaldtoday at 11:00 AM

Will they? Will someone have enough time, skill and dedication to maintain it? I don’t think using AI will by itself make a big enough difference, it’s still a lot of work to maintain a project

show 1 reply
nottorptoday at 11:10 AM

> and improve it with AI anyway

No. My impression is that most AI PRs aren't made to improve anything, but to inflate the requester's reputation as an "AI" expert.

> and feature development

There's also this misconception that more features == better...

show 1 reply
ChrisRRtoday at 2:42 PM

If people want to fork at and work in their own manner then that's fine, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't protect the project that you're personally working on

signa11today at 11:03 AM

don't mind if you do 'guv, don't mind at all.