logoalt Hacker News

taerictoday at 3:15 PM1 replyview on HN

As stated, this feels wrong. Specifically, it does not account for traits being appropriate for environment. I like to say it as what was needed for one stage could be the problem for the next stage.

That is, traits that stop registering may no longer be something that helps survival. But that does not mean they were not necessary for survival at an earlier point.


Replies

SubmarineClubtoday at 5:15 PM

How exactly does that contradict the concept of fitness?

Several examples from the paper are exactly that. E.g dark skin was better for survival in Africa, but as populations moved north light skin was strongly selected for. Given the levels of sunlight in Europe, lighter skin increased fitness.

show 1 reply