logoalt Hacker News

gobdovantoday at 10:24 AM1 replyview on HN

My comment is not long enough either to get lost in.

The prose "It also means that no ties are permitted - either I am better than my grandmother at soccer or she is better at it than me" is inaccurate for describing antisymmetry. In the same short section, you first state the correct condition:

You have x ≤ y and y ≤ x only if x = y

from which it doesn't follow that "It also means that no ties are permitted". The "no ties" idea belongs to a stronger notion such as a strict total order, not to antisymmetry.


Replies

wasabi991011today at 3:28 PM

The prose is correct.

You (presumably) aren't your grandmother, so we have x=/=y. Therefore by the biimplication, (x ≤ y and y ≤ x) is false i.e. either x ≤ y (I am better than my grandmother) or y ≤ x (my grandmother is better than me). The "neither" case is excluded by the law of totality.