logoalt Hacker News

Bendertoday at 12:59 PM1 replyview on HN

In any case, even if they, too, merely gestured to its existence

That is entirely my point. If the author wants to disable merge slashes then they need to replace the RFC I linked to with one that explicitly says what to do or not do using strong verbiage that is explicit as I explained. Blog articles and Stack Overflow threads will not set a standard.

If people interpret the RFC differently than I in that they feel it is explicit vs vague then please contact all of the web daemon maintainers to have them correct their default behavior. Just know ahead of time that two of them are quite challenging to have these discussions with.


Replies

cxrtoday at 2:49 PM

> That is entirely my point. If the author wants to disable merge slashes then they need to replace the RFC I linked to with one that explicitly says what to do or not do using strong verbiage that is explicit as I explained.

That doesn't seem to be the case. You said, "NGinx, Kube-NGINX, Apache, Traefik all default to normalizing request paths per reference of RFC 3986". That's a strong claim, not an appeal to ambiguity.

> Blog articles[…] will not set a standard.

Blog posts absolutely have the power to influence future developments. That's historically how it has worked. "RFC" stands for "Request For Comments".

show 1 reply