logoalt Hacker News

mschuster91today at 3:14 PM5 repliesview on HN

[flagged]


Replies

3eb7988a1663today at 3:51 PM

In New York, property values go up as they near transit lines. People want the option to use the public transit because it can dramatically improve access to the rest of the city.

amunozotoday at 3:21 PM

I live a 3-minutes walk from a busy train station in Switzerland and I don't even hear the trains. I also happened to live just next to it (my windows facing the rails) and that was horrible. So it's just a matter of some space and noise barriers.

show 1 reply
kccqzytoday at 4:21 PM

Your citations do not back up your claims. For example [3] was talking about immobility and poverty, but not about living near noisy traffic infrastructure.

renewiltordtoday at 4:07 PM

Yeah there are all these studies but then the end result is that the Japanese are healthier overall so when the studies and the reality have opposite results you gotta go with the reality.

show 1 reply
mmoosstoday at 4:26 PM

> Fight densification wherever someone tries to push it.

What do you really mean? On that basis, we all would live on isolated farms on the prarie.

Humans are social animals that live in groups, just like other primates. Humans like living in dense cities so much that they pay far more for much smaller spaces in the most dense cities.

That doesn't make all density good but 'fight all densification' is not a real solution. When is it good and when bad? How much desnity in those situations? Those are some of the real questions.