logoalt Hacker News

viccisyesterday at 9:15 PM1 replyview on HN

It's good that it's working for you but I'm not sure what this has to do with skill atrophy. It sounds like you never had this skill (in this case, working with that particular system) to begin with.

>I have a significantly better understanding of the codebase than I would without AI at this point in my onboarding

One of the pitfalls of using AI to learn is the same as I'd see students doing pre-AI with tutoring services. They'd have tutors explain the homework to do them and even work through the problems with them. Thing is, any time you see a problem or concept solved, your brain is tricked into thinking you understand the topic enough to do it yourself. It's why people think their job interview questions are much easier than they really are; things just seem obvious when you've thought about the solution. Anyone who's read a tutorial, felt like they understood it well, and then struggled for a while to actually start using the tool to make something new knows the feeling very well. That Todo List app in the tutorial seemed so simple, but the author was making a bunch of decisions constantly that you didn't have to think about as you read it.

So I guess my question would be: If you were on a plane flight with no wifi, and you wanted to do some dev work locally on your laptop, how comfortable would you be vs if you had done all that work yourself rather than via Claude?


Replies

post-ittoday at 1:04 AM

> If you were on a plane flight with no wifi, and you wanted to do some dev work locally on your laptop, how comfortable would you be vs if you had done all that work yourself rather than via Claude?

Probably about as comfortable as I would be if I also didn't have my laptop and instead had to sketch out the codebase in a notebook. There's no sense preparing for a scenario where AI isn't available - local models are progressing so quickly that some kind of AI is always going to be available.