> it still does mean something

Yes...which is why I said it is an indirect variable, as caused by the other things I pointed out above. Age, quality, code, utility, whether issues are addressed, interest, etc. Or fraud. Pretty cut and dry.

FWIW, I almost never star repos. Even ones I use or like. I don't see the utility for myself.

Aim for a more concise post and don't couch your statements in doubt next time if you want a productive conversation, because I don't know what you are trying to say.