logoalt Hacker News

tombertyesterday at 4:54 PM2 repliesview on HN

Honestly I think the thing that most humans appreciate is effort. Using AI tools is not inherently "bad", but these very-literally mass produced AI songs are almost by definition low-effort and as a result pretty bland and unlikeable.

Digital music has always been fine to me, as long as the song being produced feels like it took a human some amount of effort.


Replies

Forgeties79yesterday at 5:46 PM

This is a much more concise and effective way of communicating my thoughts ha

gedyyesterday at 5:09 PM

Yeah I agree with that nuance, as I personally enjoy making AI covers of songs I like in genres that I can't produce myself (old vintage blues covers of 80s new wave songs if you must know). It's a fair amount of work prompting and curating (and editing in some cases). I think they are cool and have shared a few, but they do tend to get lumped in with "ai slop" and some people take offense.

show 3 replies