logoalt Hacker News

santoshalpertoday at 12:01 AM5 repliesview on HN

So we should expect the Strait of Hormuz to be open tomorrow, then?


Replies

johnsmith1840today at 12:06 AM

Nothing in the world would have stopped iran launching cheap drones at civilian ships. Article is trying to say F35 is a problem when clearly it's not.

donavanmtoday at 12:21 AM

You're conflating operational efficacy and strategic incompetence.

Operationally, and tactically AFAIK, the US has been dominant. Strategically it appears to be a massive failure, mainly because there was no actual achievable strategic goals going in to this war. Read some of the reporting on JCS advice and cabinet level decision making leading up to the war. It's illuminating (again and again) of the risks on overly loyal advisors and getting the advice you want, not the advice you need.

knodi123today at 2:25 AM

Don't be silly. There's a third option, neither side gives up for a while.

hcurtisstoday at 12:23 AM

[dead]