logoalt Hacker News

nazgu1today at 12:29 PM5 repliesview on HN

I wonder how it is that we, as the users, allow it when iOS started allowing third-party. After that we accepted that macOS is more and more closed platform. And I'm hearing constantly something like "Yes, that's wrong, but at least platform is secure". For me security is less about how much platform is closed and more about how educated users are.

On the side note that is interesting, that when first iOS version was released Apple talked that "PWA" will be the future, and nowadays Apple do everything to suppress PWA ;)


Replies

inetknghttoday at 1:22 PM

> I wonder how it is that we, as the users, allow it

It's not like we have a choice. Either allow it or... what? Buy a different computer? With what money? Spend time installing a new OS? With what time? And for most users: with what skills?

So long as businesses make choices about the devices you own, you don't really have a choice about "allowing" it to happen.

show 1 reply
Tepixtoday at 2:03 PM

> allow it when iOS started allowing third-party

Did you mean "allowing"? Or "prohibiting"

show 1 reply
mastermagetoday at 12:41 PM

Security is not a fixed state, a closed system is not fundamentally more secure as the most vulnerable component is still within the system. The user.

show 1 reply
dangustoday at 2:17 PM

Is macOS more of a closed platform? What is more closed about it?

I totally agree that iOS is too closed down and I would say it’s part of an illegally operated duopoly, but macOS is pretty much the same as it has always been.

Apple objectively went out of their way to make sure you can install other operating systems on their silicon platform on Mac which they really didn’t have to do.

CharlesWtoday at 1:32 PM

> nowadays Apple do everything to suppress PWA ;)

Incorrect, see https://pwascore.com/ for a non-religious take. Nobody cares about PWAs, but that's not Apple's fault.

show 1 reply