> Here is an idea: UI mostly server-driven, server-side rendered with the use of HTMX

Yeah it's more HTMX evangelism.

I agree with you, but I can sort of see their point. I have successfully advocated for and implemented very barebones static HTML/CSS pages for some clients in the past, but that's rarely the right choice. They wanted deep control of the exact markup and style because they cared the most about SEO, WCAG compliance, responsive mobile design, and legacy browser support. They did not have much interactivity apart from a couple of form tags. They even worked flawlessly without javascript enabled.

I know that sounds appealing to the naive and stubborn types who hate all other web dev, but there's a catch. The "simpler" a web page is, the more testing there will need to be. You're not reducing the complexity, but just moving it somewhere else. These pages were micromanaged into oblivion with frequent audits by large teams each with their own specific concerns. The majority of my time was coordinating a circus, not writing code. In that kind of situation, there is no other choice. It was an absurd amount of testing to make that work. All that for pages that barely did anything, and questionable business value. If you want your "bullshit job", look no further than that type of web dev.

The misunderstanding I see over and over is not realizing how broad web development is. I wouldn't be doing my job if I didn't optimize for maximum flexibility of the most actively developed implementation details the client cares about. The higher value web dev is interactive functionality, not bullshit marketing pages.

All I can really say is HTMX is not a tool I see myself ever reaching for any serious production use case. It will never beat plain static pages on flexibility, speed, or scalability. It will never beat serious web app frameworks like React or Vue on developer ergonomics and tools. More generally, server-side rendering is shooting yourself in the foot the moment you need to host off a CDN or migrate. The list of downsides is endless.