logoalt Hacker News

fsfloveryesterday at 10:21 PM1 replyview on HN

> there is nothing that GrapheneOS or Micay says regarding the Librem or Pinephone that are inaccurate.

This is completely false:

> Their microphone kill switch also doesn't prevent audio recording


Replies

TommyTran732yesterday at 10:41 PM

> Their microphone kill switch also doesn't prevent audio recording

It doesn't prevent audio recording in the super paranoid "oh, the whole phone has been compromised" scenario because it is bypassable via the sensors.

In fact, it doesn't even protect the phone in normal operation, because apps with device=all can access the sensors without the whole phone being compromised.

It doesn't prevent audio recording with any normal usage either because the OS is incapable of protecting private conversations thanks to the PulseAudio socket. "Exploiting" this is significantly easier than any of the stuff involving the sensors.

show 1 reply