logoalt Hacker News

protocolturetoday at 1:49 AM1 replyview on HN

You said logical reasons but all you did was repeat standard anti marxist rhetoric a few times. Nations run on internal logic, like all things. Chinas demonstrated interests dont include me. the USA on the other hand, has a history of being unpredictable and invading without any real intent or purpose.

You appeal to history but just compare all the aggressive wars started by the USA vs China since WW2. Tell me who to be more scared of.

China hasn't even done much more than pay lip service to Marx since Deng anyway. They are just the most stable, reliable capitalist superpower right now.


Replies

CMaytoday at 6:04 AM

You mean, since the US defended China from Japan? Since the US defended South Korea from North Korea and China? Since we made the decision to allow China into global trade to lift it out of poverty and potentially liberalize its government despite the risk communism posed?

Just because you were told that the US has no intent or purpose behind its actions, doesn't mean it's true. Do you somehow believe that every country has reasons for things, except for the most powerful country in history? If so, that is a very unreasonable belief.

Some people are taught to hate the US, some people are taught to love the US, others are taught to think for themselves.

Marxists were openly interested in global imperialism, it's just that it was psychological imperialism backed by military follow-up.

I would like to see China as neutral-good and look at some Chinese brands as if they were a Sony, LG, Samsung, IKEA, Spotify, TSMC, etc. Unfortunately that is not possible: https://www.csis.org/analysis/new-challenge-communist-corpor...

Vietnam is communist too and they aren't always treating their people the best either, but they haven't been showing a lot of obvious signs of trying to expand physically or ideologically.

> China hasn't even done much more than pay lip service to Marx since Deng anyway. They are just the most stable, reliable capitalist superpower right now.

Reformists have been getting purged. There was a time where we could imagine China giving up on Marxism, but that may be less likely now.