logoalt Hacker News

parpfishyesterday at 2:09 PM7 repliesview on HN

Don’t underestimate how politicized renewables have become. You’d think essentially free energy would sell itself, but any time solar comes up in a rural community there’s a whole host of bad faith “but what about x?” comments


Replies

kilroy123yesterday at 3:34 PM

Maybe, but the data speaks for itself. Texas, a huge oil state, is loaded with wind and solar and is leading the country in battery storage right now.

show 3 replies
MetaWhirledPeasyesterday at 7:43 PM

I was shocked (pun) to hear how my relatives were each reacting to solar energy. One was rural and was concerned about nearby land getting turned into a solar farm. Another was concerned about farmland being edged out in favor of solar. And a third spent some time in emergency response on a solar farm and was off-put by their vastness and the electrical danger while traversing through them.

Coincidentally this video emerged within a day of my conversation with the three of them. I shared it; they probably didn't watch it but it sure was pertinent.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KtQ9nt2ZeGM

show 1 reply
HeyLaughingBoyyesterday at 8:59 PM

I was going to say that's weird because around here (I live in a rural community), all the new barns going up and many new houses, have solar panels on the roofs. Given the cost to run power hundreds, if not thousands of feet to an outbuilding, it's no wonder people are putting up solar.

However, my general area is somewhat upscale, so that might account for it.

himata4113yesterday at 2:16 PM

I do have a funny story to share for this specific case:

A landowner wanted to run power to their land, they got quoted 100k and possibly 250k to run less than 2 miles of powerlines.

The land owner fired back with the question of installing solar panels instead as it would be cheaper and free.

The representitive replied with: "Look around you, there's no solar panels because they don't work."

Less than 100k later, the landowner had full off-grid power via solar and a backup generator.

I guess at the end of the day they saw all the sunshine around them and said: "You're right, all that sun is mine and mine alone."

show 1 reply
saltyoldmanyesterday at 7:04 PM

Rural conservative areas in CA are highly pro-solar. Mostly because PG&E is a company many do not like.

colechristensenyesterday at 8:50 PM

I understand why.

The people excited about it turned it into a other-shaming morality issue. That kind of behavior creates opposition. It got obviously associated by the Democratic party and thus a target for opposition for Republicans. The attention economy feeds on making people upset at each other so the fire was stoked so we have a nonsensical moral battle over renewable energy.

If you want to ruin something and turn it into a needless battle, treat it like a moral imperative and start shaming people for not agreeing with you. No better way to harm a cause you care about.

show 1 reply
enraged_camelyesterday at 3:11 PM

>> You’d think essentially free energy would sell itself

I think it would if it was indeed “essentially free”. Rooftop solar is unfortunately a racket though, and companies price-gouge like crazy and also collude to keep prices inflated.

show 4 replies