logoalt Hacker News

UncleOxidanttoday at 3:38 PM1 replyview on HN

IIRC when Gemini 3 Pro came out it was considered to be just about on par with whatever version of Claude was out then (4?). Now Gemini 3 is looking long in the tooth. Considering how many Chinese models have been released since then, and at least 2 or 3 versions of Claude, it's starting to look like Google is kind of sitting still here. Maybe you're right and they'll surprise us soon with a large step improvement over what they currently have. Note: I do realize that there's been a Gemini 3.1 release, but it didn't seem like a noticeable change from 3.


Replies

cmrdporcupinetoday at 6:23 PM

As other people are saying here: the Gemini models are mostly terrible at tool use and long context management. And maybe not quite as good with finicky "detail" parts of coding generally.

Where they excel is just total holistic _knowledge_ about the world. I don't like "talking" to it, because I kind of hate its tone, but I find Gemini generally extremely useful for research and analysis tasks and looking up information.

show 2 replies