logoalt Hacker News

brodouevencodetoday at 5:52 PM1 replyview on HN

> ...to develop the powerful abstractions that then allow us to do much more, much more easily. Of course, the implicit wink here is that it takes a lot of work to be lazy

This lines up with YAGNI, but most people believe the opposite, often using YAGNI to justify NOT building the necessary abstractions.


Replies

coldteatoday at 6:01 PM

The counter-argument is that people build abstractions they deem necessary but aren't, and then they're married to that premature architecture quite often. That's what YAGNI is there to advise against.

I don't think what Fowler says here is in favor of saddling the early versions of your system with abstractions before you actually seen its use in practice, and its needs over time as requirements and conditions change.

From this "Laziness drives us to make the system as simple as possible (but no simpler!) — to develop the powerful abstractions that then allow us to do much more, much more easily." it's clear that when he talks of abstractions he means of very basic, and as simple as possible, building blocks. Like having core, orthogonal, principles in the system.

Not the kind of piling of software and pattern design abstractions e.g. the Java land in the past used to build.