logoalt Hacker News

slopinthebagyesterday at 6:22 PM2 repliesview on HN

I think the industry has leaned waaay too far into completely autonomous agents. Of course there are reasons why corporations would want to completely replace their engineers with fully autonomous coding agents, but for those of us who actually work developing software, why would we want less and less autonomy? Especially since it alienates us from our codebases, requiring more effort in the future to gain an understanding of what is happening.

I think we should move to semi-autonomous steerable agents, with manual and powerful context management. Our tools should graduate from simple chat threads to something more akin to the way we approach our work naturally. And a big benefit of this is that we won't need expensive locked down SOTA models to do this, the open models are more than powerful enough for pennies on the dollar.


Replies

NitpickLawyeryesterday at 6:28 PM

I'm hearing this more and more, we need new UX that is better suited for the LLM meta. But none that I've seen so far have really got it, yet.

grttwwyesterday at 6:31 PM

When you steer a car, there isn’t this degree of probability about the output.

How do you emulate that with llm’s? I suppose the objective is to get variance down to the point it’s barely noticeable. But not sure it’ll get to that place based on accumulating more data and re-training models.

show 1 reply