logoalt Hacker News

freehorseyesterday at 8:13 PM1 replyview on HN

I am not sure how this is "sound advice".

Maybe in this case the editor's comments were not helpful, and maybe OP is right for that. I do not see how this generalises to a rule "do not take advice from editors that reject your manuscripts".

For one, in scientific publications, when you get rejected based on reviewers' comments, chances are if you send the manuscript to another journal the article will be sent to the same reviewers, and if unchanged will be rejected again. Not taking advice into account, as a general rule, sounds like very bad advice.


Replies

raincoleyesterday at 9:35 PM

And he's clearly not talking about scientific journeys. Glad he didn't ask how HN thought before he posted this :)