logoalt Hacker News

pixel_poppingyesterday at 9:04 PM3 repliesview on HN

In privacy circles, this was always known, as Google/Apple often sends notification content to their servers (which means that it bypass the App realm).

Some people talking about it (different but in the same scope of issue): https://blog.davidlibeau.fr/push-notifications-are-a-privacy...


Replies

masselyesterday at 9:12 PM

I expect that Signal encrypts the notification data prior to sending it to Apple, then decrypts it on-device using a Notification Service Extension – this is a common pattern to avoid trusting Apple with any sensitive data.

That would mean Apple stored the cleartext on-device after decryption.

show 1 reply
6thbityesterday at 9:07 PM

in the case reported the content did not leave the device. feds retreived them directly from the phone.

rvnxyesterday at 9:12 PM

+ Messengers like Snapchat and WhatsApp;

despite "end-to-end" encryption (for WhatsApp) they are sending copy of some messages based on keywords to authorities, PRISM-like.

Officially to protect kids, but who knows what is in this keywords list.