logoalt Hacker News

krapptoday at 1:16 AM1 replyview on HN

Australia doesn't have the Second Amendment.

In the US, any gun legislation that could possibly be effective at eliminating gun violence would also by definition be unconstitutional, since there is no way to prevent gun violence to any significant degree without infringing on the right of the people to keep and bear arms.

And a Constitutional amendment to repeal or change the 2A is existentially impossible as it would require the cooperation of Southern states and would threaten the billion dollar gun lobby.


Replies

defrosttoday at 1:42 AM

Nor does the UK, nor most of the 190+ countries about the globe.

This is tangential to whether gun policy can work or not.

> In the US, any gun legislation that could possibly be effective at eliminating gun violence would also by definition be unconstitutional,

And yet many US states already have gun legislation ... and arguably more regulations and fiddly shit than Australia does.

What the US lacks is the ability to have clean, simple, uniform gun laws across all states AND uniform _enforcement_ of such laws.

show 1 reply