logoalt Hacker News

vova_hn2today at 1:50 AM3 repliesview on HN

While the engineering behind this achievement is really impressive, it doesn't feel that important in the grand scheme of things.

We had machines "beating" humans in physical tasks for a very long time. No one would be impressed by a car winning a running competition or a construction crane lifting more weight than an Olympic weightlifting champion.


Replies

jillesvangurptoday at 2:17 AM

The significance of ping pong is not beating humans but that it is a sport that depends on high precision, fast movement, and rapid responses. The aim of the game is to out maneuver the opponent and corner them such that they can't respond and adapt quickly enough. A robot beating a human means that it does this better, faster, and more precise. A few days ago, a bi pedal robot ran a a half marathon about eight or nine minutes faster than the fastest human can.

These are not the clumsy robots of a few years ago that could only do simple, pre-programmed tasks and had to work in fenced off areas because they had no awareness of anything around them (including fragile people) but self stabilizing, inhumanly fast running robots that can operate in any kind of environment and adapt to a wide variety of tasks. And then complete those tasks at very high precision and speed.

_carbyau_today at 2:37 AM

And humans have mastered radio waves for communication, washing machines for washing clothes, dishwashers for dishes etc etc.

However, the point here is not that it makes a sport redundant, but that a type of observation, calculation, and movement has been achieved.

I for one hope to see this tech in action from the customer side of a teppanyaki restaurant. It won't replace the humour of a good human teppanyaki chef but maybe I'll be able to afford it....

throwatdem12311today at 2:17 AM

We’ve had chess computers better than humans for a long time now but nobody cares about that because it’s not about winning it’s about the humanity.