logoalt Hacker News

emacdonatoday at 11:14 AM3 repliesview on HN

Ah, thanks for the clarification! Would it have been accurate then to have said:

"iff it is bounded and has countable discontinuities"?

Or, are there some uncountable sets which also have Lebesgue measure 0?


Replies

jfarmertoday at 11:25 AM

No, it's really sets of measure zero. The Cantor set is an example of an uncountable set of measure 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cantor_set

The indicator function of the Cantor set is Riemann integrable. Like you said, though, the Dirichlet function (which is the indicator function of the rationals) is not Riemann integrable.

The reason is because the Dirchlet function is discontinuous everywhere on [0,1], so the set of discontinuities has measure 1. The Cantor function is discontinuous only on the Cantor set.

Likewise, the indicator function of a "fat Cantor set" (a way of constructing a Cantor-like set w/ positive measure) is not Riemann integrable: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smith%E2%80%93Volterra%E2%80%9...

show 1 reply
ironSkillettoday at 11:19 AM

No that's not true either. A quick Google will reveal many examples, in particular the "Cantor set".

thaumasiotestoday at 11:19 AM

The Cantor set is uncountable and has Lebesgue measure 0.

show 1 reply