logoalt Hacker News

asdfman123yesterday at 6:56 PM2 repliesview on HN

> Or one can seek some supernatural mental delusions, an opiate for the people

I'm very much an atheist and a positivist too. I rejected religion growing up.

But we don't have to cede the concept of spirituality to organized religion. Spirituality is so much more than that. It's about purpose, connection, and what it means to be a human. You can practice spirituality by meditating at home, just sitting with your thoughts and feelings. No delusion or supernatural beliefs required!

When you talk about the future of mankind, our role in it, and what's the most meaningful way to live our lives -- that's what I mean by spirituality.


Replies

jimbokunyesterday at 8:06 PM

It’s just that historically there haven’t been many successful examples of atheist communities with the kind of shared deep purpose, meaning and connection you describe.

show 1 reply
card_zeroyesterday at 8:02 PM

Using a long phrase like "Purpose, connection, and what it means to be a human" seems preferable to enabling supernatural belief to slink in through the gap in the now-ambiguous word "spirituality". I say leave it to Madame Blavatsky. Oh wait that's spiritualism. Same difference.

Ooh, how about zeitgeist? I like that word. Then you'd still have spirits, but rational German ones.

show 2 replies