logoalt Hacker News

dotancohenyesterday at 8:51 PM8 repliesview on HN

Is this a non-sequiter or just poorly phrased?

  > Disk galaxies like the Milky Way form stars “inside-out” — starting from the center and working outwards through the disk. So, as a general rule, the farther out astronomers look, the younger the stars are.
Do they meant looking out from Earth (which is actually nearer to the center of a spiral arm than to either end) or out from the galactic bulge. Either way doesn't make sense.

Replies

ww520yesterday at 11:11 PM

Looking from Earth at the stars closer to the center of a galaxy, they are found to be older. Looking from Earth at the stars closer to the edge of a galaxy, they are found to be younger.

_factoryesterday at 9:01 PM

Poorly phrased. The most recent stars are on the edges. The inner stars were first, hence the “working outwards”.

malfistyesterday at 10:13 PM

When does "starting in the center" mean anything besides "starting in the center"?

The earth is not the center of the galaxy

show 1 reply
happytoexplainyesterday at 10:12 PM

I actually am not following what the ambiguity is - stars farther out from the center are younger, no?

show 1 reply
JumpCrisscrossyesterday at 10:49 PM

Try: "the farther out [from the center] astronomers look"

colechristensenyesterday at 8:59 PM

It is beyond obvious what they mean.

layer8yesterday at 9:19 PM

[dead]