logoalt Hacker News

lmctoday at 10:48 AM2 repliesview on HN

I'm not disagreeing but I was reminded of a counterexample: https://www.theregister.com/2026/01/29/birmingham_oracle_lat...


Replies

sigbottletoday at 1:14 PM

No I mean like, centralization is unfortunately the thing that just works.

I work at a company that thinks extremely deeply about interoperability issues and everybody is on the opposite side: it can be said that we were made as a response to xkcd 927, to try and solve the issue.

I think the company is right in that semantic decentralization with interoperability would be a good end goal, but I think just plain darwinism explains the necessity of the opposite.

adammarplestoday at 11:02 AM

> Although the council had planned to implement Oracle "out-of-the-box," it created several customizations including a banking reconciliation system that failed to function properly. The council struggled to understand its cash position and was unable to produce auditable accounts. It has spent more than £5 million on manual workaround labor.

Not a great example of a single centralised system. The errors came from trying to write custom reconciliation code between two systems, the ERP and the bank - perfect example of the problems OP raises.

show 1 reply