logoalt Hacker News

sakisvyesterday at 1:31 PM2 repliesview on HN

Not the original person you replied to, but as far as I'm concerned there are a few questions that could very easily indicate which side of the line is something.

E.g.

- Is it addictive?

- Does it have the potential to destroy lives?

- Does it have the potential to destroy lives in seconds?

- Does it have a strong lobbying mechanism behind it? (n.b. things that are good and nice rarely need someone to bribe people to accept them)

or simply:

- Would you be worried if your child did it?

I think the number of "yes" that you get draws a very clear line.


Replies

jmkdyesterday at 1:39 PM

Your question ramp makes sense to me except in two ways: 1. why this "destroy lives in seconds?" question? 2. where do you see sugar sitting here?

show 2 replies
egorfineyesterday at 2:08 PM

These questions sound very rational until you realize that sugar, performance cars, military technology and history lessons can tick all those boxes.

show 3 replies