logoalt Hacker News

CSMastermindtoday at 5:07 AM2 repliesview on HN

For the uninitiated, Paul Erdős was a pretty famous but very eccentric mathematician who lived for most of the 1900s.

He had a habit of seeking out and documenting mathematical problems people were working on.

The problems range in difficulty from "easy homework for a current undergrad in math" to "you're getting a Fields Medal if you can figure this out".

There's nothing that really connects the problems other than the fact that one of the smartest people of the last 100 years didn't immediately know the answer when someone posed it to him.

One of the things people have been doing with LLMs is to see if they can come up with proofs for these problems as a sort of benchmark.

Each time there's a new model release a few more get solved.


Replies

energy123today at 5:33 AM

> Each time there's a new model release a few more get solved.

I'm no expert, but based on the commentary from mathematicians, this Erdős proof is a unique milestone because the problem received previous attention from multiple professional mathematicians, and the proof was surprising, elegant, and revealed some new connections.

The previous ChatGPT Erdős proofs have been qualitatively less impressive, more akin to literature search or solving easier problems that have been neglected.

Reading the prompt[1], one wonders if stoking the model to be unconventional is part of the success: "this ... may require non-trivial, creative and novel elements"

[1] https://chatgpt.com/share/69dd1c83-b164-8385-bf2e-8533e9baba...

fulafeltoday at 6:30 AM

The article is about solving a previously unsolved one. This is a harder set of course.