logoalt Hacker News

habermantoday at 4:28 AM7 repliesview on HN

This API seems perfect for an idea I've had for a while: a de-snarkifier for social media.

Social media can be intellectually stimulating and educational, but it's also easy to get sucked into ideological sniping and flamewars, even if you didn't go looking for it. The emotional and intellectual energy spent flaming strangers on the Internet is a complete waste of human capital.

With an API like this, I assume you could have a browser extension that could de-snarkify content before showing it to you. You could ask the LLM to preserve all factual content from the post, but to de-claw any aggressive or snarky language. If you really wanted to have fun, you could ask it to turn anything written in an aggressive tone into something that sounds absurd or incompetent, so that the more aggressive the post, the more it would make the author look silly.

This could have a double benefit. For the reader, it insulates them from the personal attacks of random strangers on the Internet. Don't get me wrong, there is a time and a place for real, charged arguments about important issues that affect us all. But there is little to be gained from having those fights with strangers; on the contrary, I think it poisons the body politic when strangers are screaming at each other.

For the writer, it takes away any incentive to be snarky or rude. If other people filter their content this way, there's no point in trying to be mean to them, and no "race to the bottom" for who can be more nasty.


Replies

nsilvestritoday at 5:21 AM

This is the Soylent of written communication. Full nutritional value with an unremarkable flavor.

show 2 replies
encruxtoday at 6:41 AM

For YouTube, this already exists and I‘m using it. The extension is caller DeArrow and aims to reduce sensationalism via crowdsourcing, though I wouldn’t be surprised if top contributors are bots using LLMs.

show 1 reply
netcantoday at 5:39 AM

I think it's an interesting idea to explore.

But... It's the type of idea that is unpredictable as it comes into contact with reality. If it works, it probably works very differently from the initial idea of how it will work.

show 2 replies
dotancohentoday at 5:39 AM

Though I hate the idea of this, I can see it becoming popular in some use cases, such as schools with "safe places".

altmanaltmantoday at 6:14 AM

Don't you think its better to just curate your social media and follow communities where the default is not toxicity? This is basically a distortion layer for reality and will just encourage more echo chambers.

Also what is toxic to one person is not toxic to another depending on their subjective choices. How will you solve for this without everyone just seeing what they want to see even if reality is not like that? I feel that will just enhance the problems of social media than reduce it.

It kind of falls apart when you start to think of edge cases rather than "hey this tool will keep morons off my feed!" mentality

jurgenburgentoday at 5:12 AM

On the other hand it would make all comments sound the same and further dilute internet content into average slop.

show 1 reply
coalstartprobtoday at 4:56 AM

[dead]

show 4 replies