logoalt Hacker News

AntiUSAbahyesterday at 9:38 PM2 repliesview on HN

Thats the exact point of this experiment to define the inbetween and move it to either green or blue.

:/


Replies

D-Machinetoday at 12:34 AM

Wrong way to do it. We know from psychometrics that forced binaries like this just create junk (people disagree with the question, so just choose a forced answer based on some heuristic for each such question like "closest to my mouse / finger" or "most socially desirable" or "same as last time"). So you aren't measuring what you think when you force choice like this.

If you're going to go with linguistic self-report and a single item, you really want something like an 11-point Likert scale. A smart design might get e.g. a person's rating of "blue-ness vs. green-ness" on an 11-point scale, then determine the optimal cutpoint via e.g. clustering, logistic regression, or some other method, to really get something meaningful.

show 1 reply
antisthenesyesterday at 10:15 PM

That makes about as much sense as trying to compete for who can provide the most wrong answer for "2+2="

show 1 reply