logoalt Hacker News

simonwtoday at 12:26 AM5 repliesview on HN

Just noticed this notice added at the top of the Blender announcement of their funding from Anthropic: https://www.blender.org/press/anthropic-joins-the-blender-de...

> Notice: This announcement is causing a lot of feedback. We are actively evaluating it.

Presumably a lot of Blender users work in roles that feel threatened by AI being used for computer graphics work.

Lots of negative replies on Blursky here: https://bsky.app/profile/blender.org/post/3mkkuyq3ijs2q


Replies

hgoeltoday at 12:37 AM

I don't really get the backlash about Blender here, this isn't generative art, it's basically a natural language means of scripting blender.

This feels like the proper way to have AI act as a tool to make artist's jobs easier without taking away their creativity?

Edit: I guess they might want absolutely no AI of any sort in their tools (which seems like a strange line to draw), or is it about the data it's been trained on?

show 9 replies
jarjouratoday at 3:33 AM

I really do want to support artists, but I also feel super conflicted about what is actually at stake here if an AI agent generates a scene for me. I never would have hired a 3D artist before this moment, because there's no reason for me to. However, if I can easily poop out a 3D rendering of something custom without much time or cost, I would absolutely love to do that. How many one-off presentations or project design sessions I could have with cheap throwaway 3D artwork that provides value to explain my thought process?!

Just like AI image slop and AI book slop prove though, I highly doubt whatever Claude and Blender are cooking up will ever come close to taking a prompt like

> render a scene of a corgi sitting on a chair looking out of a window at 3 cats playing with the corgi's favorite toy.

and turning that into anything useful.

NetOpWibbytoday at 6:24 AM

People on Mastodon are losing their shit too[1].

I understand being unhappy about something but people gotta relax.

---

[1]: https://social.coop/@netopwibby/116483037092383210

giancarlostorotoday at 5:04 AM

> Lots of negative replies on Blursky

To the surprise of no one.

preommrtoday at 1:33 AM

[flagged]

show 1 reply