logoalt Hacker News

fragmedetoday at 4:02 AM1 replyview on HN

The Brightline in Florida exists, as does the Acela on the East Coast. These things are entirely possible in the US, we just don't seem to want them enough.


Replies

ssl-3today at 5:52 AM

Sorta, kinda.

Suppose in some hypothetical future, we can take the (expensive) train to our destination in Somewhere, USA, and it drops us off.

So there we are, at a train station in Somewhere, USA.

What happens next? A bus? Light rail? Uber/Lyft/taxi? A friend who has time to show up? Renting a car? What's our next move? (Lots of destinations don't have much for local public transport.)

For contrast: When I drive myself to Somewhere, I've still got my car to use after I get there. I can go anywhere I want to go, at any time I choose to do so, and I can bring as much stuff and as many people as suits me without much additional cost.

I don't have to wait around for a train. I don't have to deal with checking luggage, or retrieving luggage. I can just pop into town -- with my car -- and set forth to do whatever I want. The bags can ride along with me until I get to wherever it is that I'm crashing for the night and until then, they don't present any particular burden at all.

I might have been better-rested if I took the hypothetical train, but getting dropped off at a train station isn't a very complete solution.

show 2 replies