alt Hacker NewsWhere are these rust fans? Are they in the room with us right now?
You’ve constructed a strawman with no basis in reality.
You know what actual Rust fans sound like? They sound like Matthias Endler, who wrote the article we’re discussing. Matthias hosts a popular podcast Rust in Production where talks with people about sharp edges and difficulties they experienced using Rust.
A true Rust advocate like him writes articles titled “Bugs Rust Won’t Catch”.
> Such rewritten software packages should remain for years as optional alternatives to the originals.
This project was started a decade ago. (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7882211)
> must first present to the world the results of a huge set of correctness tests and performance benchmarks
Yeah, you can see those in https://github.com/uutils/coreutils. This project has also worked with GNU coreutils maintainers to add more tests over time. Check out the graph where the total number of tests increases over time.
> before the substitution idea is even put forward
I partly agree. But notice that these CVEs come from a thorough security audit paid for by Canonical. Canonical is paying for it because they have a plan to substitute in the immediate future.
Without a plan to substitute it’s hard to advocate for funding. Without funding it’s hard to find and fix these issues. With these issues unfixed it’s hard to plan to substitute.
Chicken and egg problem.
> less bugs
Fewer.
Those Rust fans exist on almost all Internet forums that I have seen, including on HN.
I do not care about what they say, so I have not made a list with links to what they have posted. But even only on HN, I certainly have seen much more than one hundred of such postings, more likely at least several hundreds, even on threads that did not have any close relationship with Rust, so there was no reason to discuss Rust.
Since the shameless promotion with false claims of Java by Sun, during the last years of the previous century, there has not been any other programming language affected by such a hype campaign.
I think that this is sad. Rust has introduced a few valid innovations and it is a decent programming language. Despite this, whenever someone starts mentioning Rust, my first reaction is to distrust whatever is said, until proven otherwise, because I have seen far too many ridiculous claims about Rust.